The name werther comes from goethes novel, the sorrows of young werther. One of the most famous and infamous works in the history of literature, the sorrows of young werther was goethes first work of narrative art, published in 1774. After studying suicide statistics in the united states from 1947 to 1968, phillips discovered that within two months after every frontpage suicide story, an. Social scientist coleman has specialized in the phenomenon known as the werther effect, referring to the protagonist of goethes 1774 novel, the sorrows of young werther, whose melodramatic suicide purportedly inspired widespread imitation. The longer werther effect band of entertainment celebrity could be explained by greater and positive frames of media coverage about her suicide. A fascinating example of social proof based on the research of david phillips has been dubbed the werther effect after goethes novel the sorrows of young werther. In addition to finding a link between suicide stories and subsequent suicides, he also found a link between highly publicized agression and homicides. Goethes werther and its effects the lancet psychiatry.
The result of phillips research from the 1970s was the. The novel was perfectly timed, capturing the european imagination with its portrayal of a dangerously sensitive youth driven to suicide. The book winds up with a passage in which werther dresses in boots, a blue coat and a yellow vest, sits at his desk with an open book, and shoots himself. More than one hundred years after werther was written, durkhein. The origin of the werther effect epa section of suicidology. Copycat suicide project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks. Too often were their bodies found, the tearful book beside them. The werther effect refers to the phenomenon of imitating the suicides of. All these findings, again, provide insights into the argument of the werther effect, since fiction alone in. The werther effect refers to the important role played by imitation of suicidal behaviours, when such stories are publicized or described in fact or fiction. Oct 17, 2019 the curious phenomenon of werther fever.
Contrary to durkheims assertions, the werther effect is manifested on a national and sometimes on an international scale. The werther effect find, read and cite all the research you need on. Jun 06, 2018 the phrase werther effect comes from the 1774 novel the sorrows of young werther by goethe. The werther effect is used to designate the important role played by the imitation upon the suicidal behaviours, when a suicide story is publicized, also is described in fiction. Second, we give werther a unique position in literary history. The werther effect i have been more than once intoxicated, my passions have always bordered on extravagance. If werther is more imitative than original, if something like a werther effect produced goethes novel, we must seek an explanation for the power of the novel not in goethes emotions but in literary historyor, at least, in the effect that this history had on goethe. This resulted in the book being banned in several places. The marilyn monroe group and the werther effect abstract background. The werther effect about the handling of suicide in the media. The werther effect a new study provides the strongest evidence yet that sensational media reporting of a teen suicide plays into the tendency. Goethe was the chief proponent of a movement in german literature known as sturm. In this book, the protagonist ends up committing suicide in the name of love. Werther effect the power of negative news paurav shukla.
Hence the term werther effect, used in the technical literature to designate copycat suicides. Research into causation and prevention of suicide deaths has identified a copycat phenomenon, dubbed the werther effect phillips, 1974, whereby media reporting of suicides by celebrities and wellknown figures leads to an increase in suicide deaths in the general population. The werther effect why suicide can be contagious exploring. Singleminded examination of how violent and tragic behaviors tend to replicate themselves in our ultraconnected society. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the copycat effect. The publication of the sorrows of young werther had several effects. The werther effect sociologists studying the media and the cultural contagion of suicidal behaviors were the first to recognize the copycat effect. P hillips is a professor of sociology at the university of california at san diego. It became a best seller, as well as the impetus for a spate of suicides. The werther effect was significantly apparent in korea for 6 weeks and 4 weeks, respectively, after the suicides of entertainment celebrity ms. My only awareness of the werther effect up until this point was the 1988 dark comedy heathers, in which students began killing themselves after the. A copycat suicide is defined as an emulation of another suicide that the person attempting suicide knows about either from local knowledge or due to accounts or depictions of the original suicide on television and in other media a spike of emulation suicides after a widely publicized suicide is known as the werther effect, following goethes novel the sorrows of young werther.
Contrary to durkheims assertions, the werther effect is. Mar 05, 2018 the werther effect was the term coined by the sociologist david phillips in 1974 to define the imitative effect of suicidal behavior. First published in 1774, it reappeared as a revised edition in 1787. A spike of emulation suicides after a widely publicized suicide following goethes novel the sorrows of young werther. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. How the media and popular culture trigger the mayhem in tomorrows headlines. Werther effect a popular term for an increase in suicide rates that 1 follow media coverage of suicides. According to some critics, the book is the first psychological novel, and it continues to be regarded. Celebrity suicides can inspire copycat deaths, say studies. The question for our larger project is how we might measure the werther effect in these terms how the novel is both generative of new literary forms and generated by prior ones. Once goethes book was published and grew in popularity, young men started to mimic the main character, werther, dressing in the same fashion.
Mar 11, 2020 the soasamaritans guide places an early focus on the welldocumented werther effect the link between glamorised representations of suicide, or descriptions that give specific information on methods, and rises in realworld suicide attempts. The werther effect published in suicidal behaviour and risk factors 1990. The book had a tremendous success, and many people were worried that the suicide toll in its wake might be immense. The novels popularity in europe was said to have perpetuated the imitation of werther s suicide. Apr 28, 2017 the werther effect a new study provides the strongest evidence yet that sensational media reporting of a teen suicide plays into the tendency of other kids to imitate the tragic act. In social sciences and in medicine, the term werthereffect is used as a synonym for media induced imitation effects of suicidal behaviour. Just a clarification, as the book concerns itself with the triggering effect of contagion via the media, and only senstively discusses all people, whether the suicide victims, the shooters, the people left behind, or any others of those who are. The phrase werther effect comes from the 1774 novel the sorrows of young werther by goethe.
Dating back to the high number of suicides after the publication of goethes the sorrows of young werther in 1774, it describes the apparition of copycat suicides after media reports on suicides. The sorrows of young werther study guide gradesaver. Patricia hearst became a member of the symbionese liberation army and later a homemaker, people randomly assigned to the boss in a study solved fewer problems than did those assigned to be the assistant. To test the hypotheses that certain media content is associated with an increase in suicide, suggesting a socalled werther effect, and that other. The sorrows of young werther questions and answers. In this book, the protagonist ends up committing suicide in the name of love it was such a success, that shortly after its publication, in 1774. Personally, i feel that having a set of guidelines for fiction writers is long overdue. The werther effect is a term coined by american sociologist dave phillips in 1974 to describe the phenomenon that behaviors, whether selfpreservative or destructive, are copied between humans by ideas manifested in language ex. I certainly wouldnt say that goethes book or reports of suicides in the. In the book, werther, a sensitive young artist, falls in love with a woman who is engaged to. From a sociocultural standpoint, it started the phenomenon known as the werther fever. The books publication instantly placed the author among the.
In this book, the protagonist ends up committing suicide in the name. The year after the book s publication, the theology faculty at the university of leipzig successfully petitioned officials to ban it and the werther costume on grounds of public safety. The weather channel and provide a national and local weather forecast for cities, as well as weather radar, report and hurricane coverage. The werther effect is the mimicry of suicide after a highly publicized suicide. The year after the books publication, the theology faculty at the university of leipzig successfully petitioned officials to ban it and the werther costume on grounds of public safety.
Copycat suicides may not exist goethes popular comic book, sorrows of young werther, published in 1774, allegedly inspired two imitations. The sorrows of young werther created something that is called the werther effect. The werther effect not only predicts an increase in suicide, but the majority of the suicides will take place in the same or a similar way as the one publicized. Goethe immediately became the first literary character in europe, as lord byron described him 50 years later.
Is this german novel the deadliest book in history. That one book the sorrows of young werther deviant succubus. While most extant studies have suggested that the werther effect can be found via news and electronic media, whether books would have a similarly independent role on suicide suggestion remains. The werther effect was the term coined by the sociologist david phillips in 1974 to define the imitative effect of suicidal behavior. Jul 08, 2012 an important aspect of the werther effect is the way werther is himself already an effect an outcome of a new kind of reading culture. Young men all over europe took their own lives after reading the book. Finished in six weeks of intensive writing during januarymarc. The question and answer section for the sorrows of young werther is a great resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss the novel. Nov 30, 2010 suicides as imitations of other suicides have since then been placed under the heading the werther effect. In 1974, university of california at san diego sociologist david p. To illustrate this point with the case of the marilyn monroe group convened in 1962. Phillips coined the phrase werther effect to describe the copycat phenomenon. Named after the protagonist in the sorrows of young werther, this observation is closely associated with.
In a few words, this effect refers to a wave of copycat suicides following a highly publicized one. Emotional support is important after a tragedy but, in inexperienced hands, good intentions can go wrong. In social sciences and in medicine, the term werther effect is used as a synonym for media induced imitation effects of suicidal behaviour. Suicides as imitations of other suicides have since then been placed under the heading the werther effect. Ermanno pavesi, mario di fiorino mass media influence on suicide. More than 10,000 people in germany take their own life every year in the age group of those up to 34 years, suicidality is the most common cause of death following accidents.
The story behind the werther effect is highly intriguing and chilling. Indeed, this is how we want to understand the werther effect as the transformation of literary discourse into multiple, heterogeneous and yet mutually constitutive entities. I will show that this effect is probably due to the influence of suggestion on suicide. This resulted in a ban of the book in several places. In goethe s novel, the contemporary recipient could find a lot of details to identify with. They found themselves in the same kind of despair that the protagonist of the story describes. An important aspect of the werther effect is the way werther is himself already an effect an outcome of a new kind of reading culture.
Sociologists studying the media and the cultural contagion of suicidal behaviors were the first to recognize the copycat effect. Whether effect in active shooter events 3 werther effect the werther effect is founded on the gothe novel the sorrows of young werther wherein the main character commits suicide. Request pdf on jan 1, 2018, yunsong chen and others published the werther effect revisited. Was there a suicide epidemic after goethes werther. The sorrows of young werther was impactful in ushering in the romantic age of literaturethough goethe nearly killed it off before it began. The werther effect was identified by sociologist david phillips of the university of california at san diego. In addition, the two chisquare statistics for isb in table 5 are both larger than those in table 2, suggesting that the werther effect is more statistically significant for nonfiction books than for books in general, including fiction.
Werther effect definition of werther effect by medical. The werther effect about the handling of suicide in the. May 08, 2017 the suicide researcher, david phillips, coined the term, the werther effect, to refer to the phenomenon of copycat suicides. The weather channel national and local weather radar. The tendency for suicide to incite imitation, especially if the death is highly publicized or romanticisized, is persistent, in september, 1774, goethe published the sufferings of young werther, a book that portrayed a young man who shot himself over the love of a young woman. When david phillipss 1974seminal, systematic study of suicide first directed academic attention to the link between the media and suicide, the term werther effect, after goethes 1774 novel the sorrows of young werther, was coined as a metaphor for copycat suicide trigged by the media. In the next few years so many young men dressed themselves as werther and sat at a desk with an open book to shoot themselves that the book was banned in several countries.
That one book the sorrows of young werther deviant. The copycat effect talks of vulnerable people, yes, but never, not once, labels anyone a coward. The suicide researcher, david phillips, coined the term, the werther effect, to refer to the phenomenon of copycat suicides. This effect has been studied and reconfirmed across multiple time periods and geographic. How the media and popular culture trigger the mayhem in tomorrows headlines kindle edition by coleman, loren. Why psychologists have got it wrong on reasons why. Werther s suicide was never conclusively demonstrated, but authorities were sufficiently apprehensive to ban the book in several areas, including italy gray, 1967, leipzig, and copenhagen rose, 1929.
1099 1232 450 109 196 1238 1423 968 1571 1270 1158 301 263 393 1148 407 735 541 1595 1374 1409 1574 704 1243 1506 1435 446 1541 1353 1116 1685 851 286 728 777 73 20 525 1317